The Best Bagel Shops in Brooklyn, New York According to Yelp Reviews

As an avid bagel enthusiast searching for the perfect bagels in Brooklyn? Check out this list of top rated bagel shops according to Yelp reviews!

The Best Bagel Shops in Brooklyn, New York According to Yelp Reviews

As a bagel enthusiast, I have spent many mornings searching for the perfect bagel in Brooklyn, New York. With so many options to choose from, it can be difficult to decide which bagel shop is worth your time and money. That's where Yelp comes in. With its user-generated reviews and ratings, Yelp has become a go-to source for finding the best local businesses.

So, which bagel shop in Brooklyn has the best reviews on Yelp? Let's find out.

The Bagel Store

Located in the heart of Williamsburg, The Bagel Store has been a staple in the Brooklyn bagel scene since 1996. This family-owned and operated shop prides itself on using traditional methods to make their hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels. And it seems like their customers agree. With over 1,500 reviews on Yelp and an impressive 4.5-star rating, The Bagel Store is a clear favorite among locals and tourists alike.One of the standout items on their menu is the Rainbow Bagel, which has gained viral fame on social media. But don't let the colorful exterior fool you, these bagels are just as delicious as they are Instagram-worthy.

The Bagel Store also offers a wide variety of cream cheese flavors and sandwich options, making it a one-stop-shop for all your bagel cravings.

Bagel Pub

If you're looking for a more traditional New York-style bagel, look no further than Bagel Pub. This no-frills bagel shop has been serving up fresh, hand-rolled bagels since 1982. With two locations in Park Slope and Bay Ridge, Bagel Pub has become a neighborhood favorite for its consistently delicious bagels and friendly service.What sets Bagel Pub apart from other bagel shops is their commitment to quality ingredients. They use only the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients in their bagels and spreads, resulting in a superior taste. And their customers have taken notice, with over 1,000 reviews on Yelp and a solid 4-star rating.


No list of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn would be complete without mentioning Ess-a-Bagel.

This iconic bagel shop has been a New York City institution since 1976. With locations in both Midtown and the East Village, Ess-a-Bagel has become a must-visit spot for tourists and locals alike.What makes Ess-a-Bagel stand out is their commitment to tradition. They still hand-roll and kettle-boil their bagels, resulting in a chewy and flavorful texture that is hard to beat. And with over 3,000 reviews on Yelp and an impressive 4-star rating, it's safe to say that Ess-a-Bagel has won over the hearts (and stomachs) of many.


If you're looking for a more modern take on the classic New York bagel, look no further than Bagelsmith. This trendy bagel shop has two locations in Williamsburg and Greenpoint, and has quickly become a favorite among Brooklynites.

With over 1,000 reviews on Yelp and a solid 4-star rating, it's clear that Bagelsmith is doing something right.Bagelsmith offers a wide variety of unique bagel flavors, such as jalapeno cheddar and everything spice, as well as vegan options. They also have a selection of creative sandwich options, making it a popular spot for breakfast and lunch. And with their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and making everything in-house, it's no wonder why Bagelsmith has become a go-to spot for bagel lovers.

The Winner: The Bagel Store

After scouring through thousands of Yelp reviews and trying out numerous bagel shops in Brooklyn, it's clear that The Bagel Store is the winner. With its traditional methods, unique flavors, and consistently delicious bagels, it's no surprise that this family-owned shop has won over the hearts of so many.

So next time you're in Brooklyn, be sure to stop by The Bagel Store for a taste of the best bagels in town.

Leave a Comment

All fileds with * are required